Best Practices for Upselling on Shopify: Boosting Your Average Order Value

Do you know that as much as 65% of a company’s business comes from existing customers? This statistic reveals a significant insight: the majority of your sales are likely to come from those who have already purchased from your store. Ultimately, this means you have a golden opportunity to increase your revenue through upselling to these customers. This article explains Shopify upselling best practices to ensure your upselling tactics culminate into higher average order value for your store.

Why is Upselling Important for Shopify Stores?

Upselling as a sales strategy is about encouraging or persuading customers to purchase a more expensive or upgraded version of an item they’ve chosen. The primary purpose of upselling is for the merchant to make a larger sale and maximize profit. Well-executed upselling strategies can bring in more revenue for your business. For instance, customer lifetime value (CLV) is an often-talked-about metric for many businesses. CLV refers to how much a customer is worth to a company over the course of their relationship with the brand. Upselling can be a simple and effective way of increasing CLV by encouraging repeat purchases and enhancing the overall value a customer brings over their relationship with your brand. 

Further, with upselling, you can increase the average order value of your customers. The average order value measures the amount spent by a customer in a single transaction. Upsells can potentially increase your store’s average order value by 20%. A higher average order value translates to more revenue for your business, and upselling to customers who are already committed to making a purchase can help you achieve this. Also, 40 percent of U.S. consumers say they have purchased something more expensive than planned because their experience was personalized. This means highly personalized upsell offers are pretty viable for increasing your store’s AOV.

When done strategically, upselling can improve the customer experience by adding more value. It’s often seen just as a way to increase sales, but it’s much more than that. It’s key to making the bond between businesses and their customers stronger. Recommending relevant products for upsells reflects a business’s understanding of its customer’s needs and preferences and demonstrates a commitment to their satisfaction. This approach helps customers discover products or services they may not have initially considered, which could significantly enhance their experience or meet their needs more effectively. In doing so, upselling becomes a personalized service that enriches the customer journey, leading to a deeper connection and increased loyalty towards the brand.

How to Practice Best Upselling Techniques on Shopify

Using upselling tactics successfully on Shopify has many parts. From ensuring that your offers are well-timed to making sure that you’re presenting the right products for upselling, merchants need to balance customer engagement with profitability perfectly. Here are some Shopify upselling best practices.

Identifying the Right Products for Upselling

The truth is that some products will do better than others when you present them for upselling. Thus, you should use data analytics to understand which products are frequently bought together or complement each other. This can help you identify potential upsell opportunities that are relevant to the customer. 

In addition, profitability is still important. Prioritize products with higher profit margins as upsell options. However, ensure these items are still within a reasonable price range of the original item to maintain customer interest. It is best to choose products of equal or higher quality that add genuine value to the customer’s purchase. The upsell should feel like a natural enhancement, not an unnecessary add-on.

Personalizing Upsell Offers Based on Customer Behavior and Purchase History

Personalization is an element of upselling you shouldn’t ignore, as 70% of consumers spend more with companies offering personalized customer experiences. Personalized upsell offers are almost always relevant to the customer. Use Shopify’s analytics and customer profiles to tailor their upsell offers based on individual shopping behaviors, past purchases, and browsing history. You should also create customer segments (e.g., new customers, loyal customers, high spenders) to offer more targeted and relevant upsells.

Timing and Presentation of Upsell Offers

Being overly pushy and presenting your upsell offer at the wrong time is a recipe for disaster.  Present upsell offers at moments when customers are most likely to accept them, such as after adding an item to their cart or during checkout. Avoid overwhelming customers with offers too early in their shopping journey.

It is equally important to ensure that your upsell offers are presented in a way that is visually appealing and non-intrusive. Use clean design elements and clear messaging that highlights the value of the additional products. Emphasize how the upsell adds value to their current selection. For example, offer a product bundle at a discounted rate or highlight the benefits of the additional item.

Integrating Upselling into the Customer’s Shopping Journey

Incorporate upsell offers naturally within the shopping journey, such as on product pages, in the shopping cart, or during checkout. Make sure they enhance the shopping experience rather than disrupt it. These days, a lot of transactions are done on mobile devices.  Ensure that upsell offers are optimized for mobile devices. Continuously test different upsell strategies, including product combinations, timing, and presentation formats. Use A/B testing to determine what works best and refine your approach accordingly.

Introducing Amai Upsell+ (Shopify Upselling App)

The Amai Upsell+ app is a straightforward solution for Shopify stores looking to boost their upselling efforts. It offers a range of discount and upsell options that integrate easily, making it simple to increase order values and encourage more purchases. With 24/7 support and a user-friendly setup, it’s a reliable choice for enhancing sales strategies without overwhelming effort. 

Limitations of Shopify’s Native System and Competitors

Shopify’s native features for upselling and cross-selling are somewhat basic and lack deep customization options. Merchants seeking to tailor their upselling strategies precisely—such as creating highly specific offers based on customer behavior, order history, or product combinations—might find the native options restrictive.

Merchants also face issues when using Shopify apps to upsell. These issues range from installation and integration issues to technical bugs. The Amai Upsell+ app is easy to install and integrate into your existing Shopify themes. There are guides and tutorials to help users troubleshoot any potential integration and technical issues. Poor customer support and inaccurate analytics are also problems people encounter with some of these upsell apps on Shopify. Amai Upsell+ app offers 24/7 customer support to attend to issues if they ever arise, and the app’s analytics dashboard is designed to provide accurate and insightful data, ensuring that merchants can trust the information to make informed decisions. 

Features and Advantages of Amai Upsell+

  • Easy to Install: The app’s installation process is simply straightforward. To install Amai Upsell+ on your Shopify store, go to its Shopify App Store page and click “Add app.” Log in if needed, then approve the requested permissions on your Shopify admin dashboard and click “Install app” to add it to your store. You’ll then be ready to customize the app in your Shopify admin. For any installation or setup issues, Amai Upsell+ offers 24/7 customer support to help you through the process.
  • 1-Click Upsell: This feature simplifies the process of increasing order values by presenting customers with attractive tiered discounts. With just one click, customers can easily add more items to their cart to reach the next discount tier, enhancing their shopping experience and encouraging larger purchases. This seamless integration ensures that customers are always aware of the best deals available to them, prompting immediate action without navigating away from their current page.
  • Product Options Upsell: Elevate your sales strategy by offering premium product options and add-ons directly alongside your base products. This approach simplifies the upselling process and significantly enhances the customer’s shopping experience by providing them with customizable options that cater to their preferences. As a result, you can effectively increase your average order value by encouraging customers to opt for higher-priced items or additional features.
  • Customizable Upsell Widget on Cart Page: The Upsell+ app allows for easy setup of an upsell widget right on the cart page. This widget can be customized to include Product Recommendations, Frequently Bought Together suggestions, Pop-up Upsells, and Service Upsells, all tailored to fit your store’s theme and layout preferences.
  • Geographically Targeted Upsells: Tailor your upselling strategy based on customer location with our “Upsell by Countries” option. This feature allows you to apply tier pricing and upsells exclusively to customers from selected countries, ensuring your offers are relevant and targeted.

    This level of customization ensures that your upselling tactics are more effective and culturally and regionally appropriate, potentially increasing acceptance rates and reducing friction in the buying process.
  • Intuitive Interface: Amai Upsell+ boasts an intuitive interface that simplifies the setup and management of upsell and cross-sell strategies. Unlike Shopify’s more basic offerings and the often complex interfaces of competitors, Amai Upsell+ allows for quick implementation of sophisticated sales tactics without a steep learning curve.
  • Advanced Analytics and Reporting: Amai Upsell+ delivers in-depth analytics and performance tracking, enabling merchants to measure the success of their upselling strategies accurately. These insights go beyond the basic analytics offered by Shopify, offering detailed data on upsell conversion rates, average order value increases, and customer behavior patterns.

Useful Tips

  • Place upsell offers in non-intrusive areas, such as the cart page or during checkout, to enhance rather than disrupt the shopping experience.
  • Tailor your upsell offers to match customer preferences and buying habits for more personalized shopping experiences.
  • Create logical product bundles that offer real value to the customer, making the upsell offer feel like a natural choice.
  • With a significant portion of online shopping done via mobile devices, make sure your upsell offers are mobile-friendly.
  • Monitor the conversion rates of your upsell offers to identify what works and what doesn’t.

Summary and Advice

Upselling is a pivotal tactic for Shopify stores looking to boost their sales and enhance customer satisfaction. Merchants can unlock greater profitability and deepen customer relationships through strategic product recommendations and upgrades. When it comes to incorporating Amai Upsell+ into your Shopify store, it’s all about tapping into advanced features designed to make upselling intuitive and effective. The app’s ability to offer personalized, seamless upsell experiences can significantly elevate your store’s performance.

Elevate Your Sales Strategy and Maximize Revenue with Upsell+
Try it for free on Shopify